Friday, 1 February 2013

Unreasonable behaviour

This morning my son sent me this youtube clip.


Now this led me to consider the most frequently used ground for divorce, that the Respondent has behaved in such a way that the Petitioner cannot reasonably be expected to live with the Respondent, aka unreasonable behaviour.  Now on the evidence of the video, I don't see that the husband would have much of a problem - it must be unreasonable for either spouse to take active steps to enter into a relationship with another person while still married.  However, here's the conundrum - is the husband's act of trashing the car unreasonable behaviour or is it a natural, predictable and reasonable response to a seriously provocative act?  Can his wife cite it as a reason for divorcing him?

To become rather more lawyerly, we now know from Imerman v. Tchenguiz that even within marriage, spouses seem to have some right to confidentiality.  To put it another way, a spouse can act unlawfully by seeking to uncover material or information which the other spouse has maintained confidentially - crudely put, secrets which one spouse has kept from the other.  So does this wife have a reasonable expectation of privacy in relation to her online shenanigans?  Would your answer be different if she had had the commonsense to use a different name online to conceal her identity?


Blog Disclaimer: Nothing in www.austinkempfamilylaw.blogspot.com blog should be construed as legal advice. If you require legal advice upon any family law related matter then you should instruct a solicitor. Any links to other blogs or web sites are provided for convenience only and Austin Kemp Solicitors cannot accept any responsibility for the contents of such linked blogs/sites.

2 comments:

  1. Above article shared very useful information about how our behaviour is responsible of dissolution of our marriage life. I really thankful to sharing such a nice post.

    LAPD corruption

    ReplyDelete
  2. People often write off legal representation thinking that adjusters and insurance companies will cover all bases with compassion and understanding. The truth is your injuries, your emotional pain, your lost wages, your medical expenses and much more are simply dismissed. Insurance companies are in the business to make money, not lose it. They settle claims for as little amounts as possible, leaving you out in the cold. The Greenway Law Firm will not let insurance companies take advantage of you and your situation. Atty. Greenway is an aggressive personal injury lawyer who is ready to handle all of your paperwork to ensure you settle for nothing less than what you deserve.
    Car Accidents in austin

    ReplyDelete